4255 San Benito Road
Price History Original $1,275,000 → Last $1,149,000 → Sold $1,125,000
Virtual Tours & Property Media
Not Available (note: A Matterport tour may be on the property website.)
Photos
1 PhotoProperty Description
Set on 2.68 acres of rare, pancake-flat land, 4255 San Benito Road is a property that immediately invites possibility. The fully renovated 3-bedroom, 2-bath home is move-in ready, blending modern comfort with timeless character. The 2025–26 remodel brought a fresh, cohesive, and thoughtfully designed feel to the home, with updates touching nearly every surface.
This included new flooring, beautifully updated bathrooms, a kitchen upgrade with new appliances, fresh paint, and backyard landscaping. Beyond the 1,583-square-foot main residence, a charming 400-square-foot redwood building dating back to 1928, affectionately known as the "schoolhouse," offers flexibility; it could be perfect as a studio, guest space, gym, or creative retreat. Two additional redwood structures provide even more room for storage, workshops, or future potential.
From there, the property opens up, whether you envision horses, 4-H projects, an ADU, or simply space to grow, the flat, usable acreage gives you the freedom to bring your vision to life. The fully fenced backyard features a patio and garden beds, creating an inviting outdoor space for everyday living, while the acreage beyond becomes your canvas. Once a Christmas tree farm, the property still benefits from a well and irrigation infrastructure, ready to support whatever comes next.
A rare combination of thoughtful updates, historic charm, and usable land, this is more than a home; it’s an opportunity to build something lasting and make it entirely your own.
Basic / Listing Information
Size & Layout
Interior
Exterior / Lot
Parking
Utilities / Energy / Rural Features
HOA / Community
Schools / Location
Tax / Zoning
Ownership / Other Listing Details
Local & Market Information
Property & Market Context
This 3-bedroom, 2-bath Atascadero single-family home offers 1,583 sq ft of living area on a 116,741 sq ft lot.
For context, its sold price of $1,125,000 is about 30% above the 2026 year-to-date through October 9, 2026 median closed single-family home price of $865,000 in Atascadero.
Its 116,741 sq ft lot is about 253% larger than the 33,106 sq ft median lot size for closed single-family homes in Atascadero during the same period.
Local Market Tidbit
Through October 9, 2026, 73% of closed single-family homes in Atascadero were single-story, ranking Atascadero 3rd among 14 SLO County communities.
The information in this section is independently compiled or calculated by SLO County Homes and is not provided by the listing broker or CRMLS. Market comparisons use saved SLO County Homes statistics for the period shown and are for general informational purposes only.
IDX Information
Based on information from CRMLS as of September 30, 2026 at 12:03 PM PDT.
The information being provided is for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Property information is supplied by the listing broker and/or other sources and may be subject to errors, omissions, or changes without notice.
Properties displayed on this website may be listed by a real estate brokerage other than SLO County Homes.